...

product search

How To Choose PDC Cutters For Drilling

Blog 270

The core of choosing the right PDC cutting teeth is “precise matching”. To put it bluntly, it is to accurately number the geometric shape of the cutting tooth (for example, for the pursuit of high drilling speed flat-top type or for the durable semi-spherical type) with the hardness of the formation, and then to pick the grade of diamond to find a balance between cost and performance.

Next, I’m going to talk about the boring parameters in the specifications, especially the hidden trade-offs (Trade-offs) that manufacturers usually don’t take the initiative to emphasize-this is the key to expert selection.

Optimal choice of PDC cutters for drilling

According to the on-site accidents I have dealt with, choosing the wrong tooth shape is often the first major incentive for the premature failure of the drill bit or the failure of ROP (rate of penetration). Let’s simplify the matter and get to the point.

The Flat Cutter: The “coolie” in pursuit of speed”

Best application scenario: In soft to medium-hard, non-abrasive formations such as shale, mudstone and sandstone, if you want to soar ROP to the highest, you must be right to choose it.
What it is: The features are very obvious, with a flat and very aggressive cutting surface.
Note: This sharp cutting edge is very fragile in hard formation or interlayer formation, easy to collapse (Chipping), wear fast.

Spherical/Dome Teeth (The Dome/Spherical Cutter): Durability Champion

Best application scenario: used for harsh conditions with extremely hard, high abrasiveness or high impact, such as conglomerate and granite. It works more like crushing and cracking rock than shearing.
What it is: The top is smooth and round, with no sharp edges.
Note: Its ROP is significantly lower than that of flat teeth. If the primary goal of the shift is to speed up, don’t use this.

The Conical Cutter: Balanced hybrids

Best application scenario: The pangold option for medium-hard to hard formations has a good balance between ROP and impact resistance. This is one of the most used designs on the market today.
What it is: The pointed conical shape combines the aggressiveness of flat teeth and the durability of spherical teeth.

Comparison of different PDC cutting teeth

Fine adjustment with chamfer (Chamfer) and angle (Rake Angle)

Chamfer (Chamfer): The small bevel on the cutting edge. Don’t underestimate this small detail. The larger the chamfer, the stronger the strength and impact resistance of the cutting edge, but at the cost of a little sacrifice of aggressiveness.
Rake Angle: The relative angle of the cutting surface to the rock. Positive inclination (Positive) is more aggressive (eating soft rock fragrance), while negative inclination (Negative) is stronger in structure and suitable for hard bones.
My rule of thumb: first look at the geological report to determine the general direction (flat, spherical or conical), and then fine-tune it through chamfering and inclination. This is like cooking, the main material is selected, and the temperature has to be controlled by these two parameters.

In order to facilitate comparison, I have compiled the following table:

Cutting Teeth TypeRole and Shape FeaturesBest ScenarioPerformance and Remarks
Flat tooth (Flat)speed acts as <br> flat, aggressive cutting surface.Soft to medium hard <br> non-abrasive formations (shale, sandstone, etc.).Pros: Very high ROP. <br> Disadvantages: easy to collapse in hard formation or interlayer, fast wear.
DomeDurable King <br> Smooth, rounded, with no edges.Extremely hard/highly abrasive <br> high impact conditions (conglomerate, granite).Advantages: High impact resistance by crushing/cracking rocks. <br> Disadvantages: ROP is significantly lower and is not suitable for catching up time.
Tapered teeth (Conical)balance hybrid <br> sharp conical shape.Medium hard to hard <br> The current versatile all-rater.Advantages: both the aggressiveness of flat teeth and the durability of spherical teeth. <br> Balance: Excellent compromise between ROP and impact resistance.
ParameterDefinitionAdjustment & Effect
ChamferA small bevel on the cutting edge.Larger Chamfer: Significantly increases edge strength (impact resistance) but slightly sacrifices aggressiveness.
Rake AngleThe angle of the cutting face relative to the rock.Positive: More aggressive (best for soft rock).Negative: Stronger structure (best for hard rock).

Selecting the Right Grade and Quality

If the shape determines the applicable scene, then the grade of the cutting tooth determines how well it can do in this scene.

Diamond particle size and grade: coarse particles of diamond cut fast, but the wear resistance is slightly worse; fine particles of the opposite. High-end suppliers often offer a variety of grades, allowing you to choose between cost and performance under extreme operating conditions.
Thermal stability (Thermal Stability): This is the “heart” of the PDC cutter “. In high-temperature deep wells, ordinary PDC (which can usually only withstand about 750°C) can easily fail because the catalyst metal will cause graphitization (graphitize) of the diamond. Be sure to specify high-end cutters that have undergone a decobalation process (leaching process), which removes the catalyst and can increase the thermal stability to 1200°C.
Quality Control (QC): A reliable manufacturer must have strict QC procedures, such as vertical lathe (VTL) testing to measure wear resistance and impact strength. Remember to request QC documents as a standard action in the procurement process.

PDC cutting edge

5 key questions you must ask your supplier before signing a contract

Don’t rush to sign, first throw these questions to them and see if the other party is professional:

  • “According to my formation report, which combination of shape and chamfer is recommended? What is the reason?”
  • “How thermally stable is this product and has it been Leached?”
  • “Can you provide field data or case studies of this cutting tooth in similar downhole conditions?”
  • “How do you ensure batch-to-batch consistency? Can you share your QC process?”
  • “If we encounter premature wear, what is your technical support and failure analysis process?”

On the Manufacturing Process and Frontier of PDC Cutting Teeth

Process principle:

Briefly, micron-sized synthetic diamond powder is sintered onto a tungsten carbide substrate at a pressure in excess of 5.5 GPa and a high temperature of 1400°C. The metal catalyst in the substrate (usually cobalt) will melt and penetrate into the diamond layer, promoting the formation of strong bonds between the diamonds, and finally forming a dense polycrystalline diamond layer (Polycrystalline Diamond layer).

Research Frontiers:

Current research and development focuses on catalyst-free synthesis, optimization of bonding interfaces (such as non-planar interfaces) to deal with residual stresses caused by thermal expansion mismatch, and introduction of nanomaterials to enhance toughness. These may sound academic, but the future breakthroughs in drilling efficiency are in these details.

About the Author

My name is Billy, and I’m an independent drilling technology consultant with over 19 years in the energy sector. My career began on the front lines as a field engineer, giving me a practical, hands-on understanding of how equipment really performs downhole, not just how it looks on a spec sheet.

I’ve since advised major oil & gas operators on multi-million dollar procurement decisions, and my mission now is to share that knowledge. I bridge the gap between manufacturer claims and real-world performance to help engineers and procurement managers make decisions that boost efficiency and protect the bottom line.

Expand more!